Problem Set 2
Problem Set 2
- Analyze the logical forms of the following statements.
- If anyone in the dorm has the measles, then everyone who has a friend
in the dorm will have to be quarantined.
- Jane saw a bear, and Roger saw one too.
- Every number that is larger than
is larger than
- If there is a number
such that
and there is a number
such that
then
is between
and
- Anyone who has bought a Rolls Royce with cash must have a rich uncle.
- If nobody failed then test, then everybod who got an A will tutor someone who got a D.
- If anyone in the dorm has the measles, then everyone who has a friend
in the dorm will have to be quarantined.
- Consider the following incorrect theorem:
Theorem 1 Suppose
is a natural number larger than
and
is not a prime
number. Then
is not a prime number.
- What are the hyptheses and conclusion of this theorem?
- Show that the theorem is incorrect by finding a counterexample.
- What are the hyptheses and conclusion of this theorem?
- Suppose
and
Prove that if
then
- Suppose
is a real number and
Prove that if
then
- Suppose
and
are real numbers,
and
Prove
that if
then
- Suppose
and
are real numbers and
Prove that if
then
- Consider the following theorem.
Theorem 2 Suppose
is a real number and
If
then
- What wrong with the following proof of the theorem?
Proof. Suppose
Then
Therefore if
then

- Give a correct proof of the theorem.
- What wrong with the following proof of the theorem?
- Suppose
and
and
are disjoint. Prove that if
then
- Use proof by contradiction to prove the following theorem.
Theorem 3 Suppose
and
Prove that
- Use proof by contradiction to prove the following theorem.
Theorem 4 Suppose
and
and
are not both elements of
Prove that
- Consider the following incorrect theorem.
Theorem 5 Suppose
and
are real numbers and
Then
and
- What is wrong with the following proof of the theorem?
Proof. Supose the conclusion of the theorem is false. Then
and
But
then
, which contradicts the given information that
Therefore, the conclusion must be true.

- Show that the theorem is incorrect by finding a counterexample.
- What is wrong with the following proof of the theorem?
- Prove that if
and
are disjoint, then
- Suppose
is a real number.
- Prove that if
then there is a real number
such that
- Prove that if there is a real number
such that
then
- Prove that if
- Prove that for every real number
, if
then there is a real
number
such that
- Prove that if
and
then
- Suppose
. Prove that for every set
- Prove
- A sufficient condition for the demand for a good to incresae when its
price falls is that it is a normal good.
- A necessary but not sufficient condition for the demand for a good to decrease when its price falls is that it is an inferior good.
- A sufficient condition for the demand for a good to incresae when its
price falls is that it is a normal good.
Jennifer Anne Thacher 2008-09-05
